Palm Comments on Apple Multi-Touch Patents 9
Dieter posted up an article on Wednesday about an Apple exec talking lawsuits at the Apple Quarterly Conference call. Yep, Apple COO Tim Cook said that if their competition ripps off Apple's intellectual property, they'd go after them. Tim stated that they weren't mentioning any specific company. LOL, no need to mention a "specific" company though, huh? I'm sure that everyone knew exactly which company Cook was referring to.
Rene Ritchie over at our sister site The iPhone Blog got wind of a PC Mag article in which Palm has commented on Apple's possible lawsuit references.
From the PC Mag article:
A spokeswoman at Palm said Thursday that the company has not been contacted by Apple's legal team, to her knowledge. "Palm has a long history of innovation, obviously reflected in our own products and our own robust apps portfolio," she said. "We have long been recognized for our fundamental patents in the mobile space. If we're faced with legal action, we're confident that we have the tools to defend ourselves."
When asked whether gestures like "pinching" were universal, or belonged to Apple, the Palm spokeswoman said that "our position is that multitouch has been around a long, long, long time before Apple introduced it."
In his recent article, Dieter referenced a few patents Palm could probably sue over; one of them being 'cradle for synchronizing data'. Another interesting one is a patent for turning off the radio via software. Hmmm, I do believe I used something very similar while in a hospital waiting area yesterday. It was when I had to turn off the "airplane mode" on my iPhone when I saw a sign letting me know that all cellphones should be turned off.
Looks like things could get pretty prickly in the lawsuit arena. We'll be watching to find out what happens. Stay tuned....
9 Comments
I seriously doubt anything is going to come of this, they are both just going to fight and end up dropping it because of something else. I hope apple is a little scared though because this contiunes innovation!! Best way to expand and develop new technology
Oh, I think it really depends on how well the Pre does when it comes out. If it does extremely well, Apple will pursue with their lawsuit calling foul. If it doesn't, Apple will move on. If you think about it, why is Apple waiting if they feel that Palm has infringed on their so-called patents. In the end, if this does go to court, I feel that Palm will prevail. It doesn't really matter if Apple has tons of money (of course, it does help). Many of the things that Apple is claiming has been around for many year prior to the iPhone coming out. Furthermore, all of the phone manufacturers have touch screen phones that act similar to the iPhone. How come Apple hasn't sued them yet? Mainly because none of them hasn't been a threat to the iPhone. Also, none of them is in the US market as well. Apple's main source of income primarily comes from the US and anything that threatens that they will call foul.
re: "our position is that multitouch has been around a long, long, long time before Apple introduced it."
Heh. How does one "introduce" something that's been around a long time?
I would guess they meant something like:
"our position is that multitouch has been around a long, long, long time before Apple introduced it to consumers."
or "Apple introduced it to the masses."
Do not forget, Apple has a history of stealing technology and suing others that use the same techology. Apple stole the window and desktop metaphors from Xerox PARC. Apple then sued Microsoft for Windows. Eventually, Xerox sued Apple, but a judge denied their claim because they waited so long to file suit.
From Wikipedia:
The first successful commercial GUI product was the Apple Macintosh, which was heavily inspired by PARC's work; Xerox was given Apple stock in exchange for engineer visits and an understanding that Apple would create a GUI product. Much later, in the midst of the Apple v. Microsoft lawsuit in which Apple accused Microsoft of violating its copyright by appropriating the use of the "look and feel" of the Macintosh GUI, Xerox also sued Apple on the same grounds. The lawsuit was dismissed because Xerox had waited too long to file suit, and the statute of limitations had expired[2]. However, some dispute the degree to which the Apple interface was derived from Xerox designs. Indeed, prior to Apple's visits to PARC, its Macintosh project more closely resembled the Valdocs operating system of the Epson QX-10.
Was the quoted phrase the whole original sentence, though? If it was excerpted from a longer statement, "it" might have referred to the iPhone rather than multitouch as a concept.
That's the sound bite effect for you, though.
"It was when I had to turn off the "airplane mode" on my iPhone when I saw a sign letting me know that all cellphones should be turned off."
I'm sure you meant you turn ON the airplane mode so that the radio is OFF... Try explain that to your grandma! :)
You go Palm, don't you budge. Apple has no right trying to claim multi-touch when it has been around for such a long time. Now let's see if you can deliver a better multi-touch experience than them...
Brand new mobile phone , laptop , come with complete
accessories with one year international warranty.
Emaill address: applemac-inc@hotmail.com
HTC TOUCH PRO2..............$500USD
Sony Ericsson Idou Black Unlocked GSM..$550usd
Samsung i8910 Omnia HD Unlocked..$500usd
HTC Touch HD ..........$500usd
HTC Touch Pro ..........$400usd
HTC Touch Diamond ...$350usd
Samsung omnia i900.....$400usd
Apple iphone 3G 16gb........$300usd
Sony ericsson C905.........$500usd
Nokia n96 16gb...$500usd
Apple iphone 16gb..$350usd
Sony ericsson xperia x1..$400usd
Apple iphone 8gb.....$300usd
Nokia n95 8gb.......$300usd
Ps3 60gb.............$300usd
HTC Touch Pro speciffication..
2.8'' VGA display
Windows Mobile 6.1 Professional with HTC TouchFLO 3D interface
3.2 megapixel camera
512MB internal memory
288MB RAM (what a weird number)
microSD memory card slot
GPS navigation
TV output
Bluetooth connectivity
GPRS/EDGE/HSDPA/HSUPA connectivity
We make shipment via Ups and Fedex shipping company 2days
deliver worldwide.
If you are interested in buying our product contact us via
Email address: applemac-inc@hotmail.com
We are authorise mobile phones,laptops, and video games distributors. We deal on brand
new original unlocked mobile phones.Our prices are wholesale prices and we can
send to you on request.We operate a 100% return policy withing 90 days and we
are commited to our customers satisfaction and happiness. We render quality and
effective services and We are working with fear of GOD, You can never regret
doing business with us. You can contact us via email for more information.
"Buy 3 items and get 1 free
MSN MESSENGER
================
phonesplaza@hotmail.com
bestmobile001@hotmail.com
Contact Name: Mario Vasquez
ORDER INFORMATION :
Shipping Method : FedEx and UPS.
Delivery Time : 2/3 Days.
HERE ARE SOME OF OUR NEW OFFER AVAILABLE IN STORE NOW:
======================================================
*Nokia N97.........................$350
*Nokia 6260 slide......................$300
* Nokia 5800 XpressMusic...................$300
* Nokia 5030 XpressMusic...................$300
*Nokia E63.......................................$330
*Sony Ericsson Idou.........................$350
*Sony ericsson C905.........$300usd
*O2 XDA Guide........................$350
*Samsung i8910 Omnia HD Unlocked...............$300usd
*samsung s5230........................$300
* Samsung S9402 Ego..................$300
* Samsung M7500 Emporio Armani...........$350
*Samsung i8510 INNOV8............$330
*Samsung S3030 Tobi...............$350
* Sonim XP3 Enduro.....................$400
* Motorola VE66........................$300
*HTC Touch HD ..........$300usd
*HTC Touch Diamond ...$350usd
*HTC Touch Pro 2.......................$400
* LG Incite................................$300
*LG KP500 Cookie.....................$300
* LG KF900 Prada........................$330
* Sony Ericsson S302...................$300
* BlackBerry Bold 9000.................$350
* BlackBerry Curve 8900............$350
* BlackBerry Storm 9500.............$350
APPLE IPHONES
===================
Apple Iphone 3g 16GB $250
Apple Iphone 32GB $200
Apple Iphone 16GB $ 200
Apple Iphone 8GB $ 150
Apple Iphone 4gb $150
NOKIA MOBILE PHONES
========================
Nokia N97 With 32GB..............$350
Nokia N96 With 16GB ..............$250usd
Nokia 6260 slide......................$300
Nokia 8800 Gold Arte..............$250
Nokia E63.....................$250
Nokia 5800 XpressMusic...................$280
Nokia N95 With 8GB.........$200usd
GAME CONSOLE
===========================
XBoX 360 Premium console ... ..200usd
XBoX 360 pal verrsion..........$170usd
Nintendowii.....................200usd
Nintendo wifi..........$220usd
Ps2.............................160usd
Playstation 3 20GB..............150usd
Playstation 3 60GB..............250usd
Playstation 3 80GB...........$200
PSP...................$60
Xbox 360.................. $100
Nintendo Wii ...............$100
We fast delivery via UPS and FedEx shipping company 2 days
Providing OK
E-mail us back if you are interested in buying our product:
For information
==============
MSN MESSENGER
================
phonesplaza@hotmail.com
bestmobile001@hotmail.com
Contact Name: Mario Vasquez