Review: Jot It 14
Note taking applications are quickly becoming a dime a dozen in the App Catalog, and only the ones that take a unique approach or offer high levels of functionality can hope to succeed. Jot It, which is currently selling for $1.99 in the App Catalog, doesn’t offer much more in terms of functionality that its contemporaries in the catalog, but the way it approaches user interface is indeed unique.
Features and use
The first thing you’ll notice when you start the app is that the card it lives in closes almost immediately, leaving you with an icon in the notification area. Tapping on the notification area brings up a small menu enabling you to look at all of your notes in Jot It! or add a new note. It’s a unique approach to be sure, but I get a fair deal of text messages and emails throughout the day, and I’d prefer to have the notification area saved for items that I need to act on, not static controls for a passive application.
Note creation is straight forward. Tap on “Add Note” and you’re taken directly into the note creation scene where you can start typing right away, as well as pick which category your note will live in. You can have up to 5 user defined categories at any one time that can be modified with different names and colors to differentiate them. There isn’t a “title” field, so the first line in a note ends up being the title. Thankfully, the entire list of notes – which are scanned in their entirety – can easily be searched from the All Notes scene by simply beginning to type.
The preferences menu could stand an overhaul, as the entirety of the configuration options reside in one big, long, monochromatic list and is hard on the eyes. From here, you can set notes to be automatically emailed to a specified email address upon creation or edit, categories can be turned on or off and renamed, category colors picked and more.
I did run into some performance issues while testing the app. I’d occasionally run into the dreaded “Too many cards” error when I was only running the application, and I’d occasionally have notifications come in only to be displayed as large white rectangles. None of them were show stoppers, but they were significant enough to bear mentioning.
Summary
In the end, Jot It is very much a run of the mill note taking app, and its biggest differentiator – that one of the most important part of its UI sits in the notification area – ends up being more of a hindrance as it can add clutter to an already busy aspect of the UI in webOS. While I do laud the developer for thinking outside of the box, I’d much prefer more robust note management capabilities, such as categories, to novel uses of the notification area. Beyond that, markup options beyond the basics are missing, and efficient note management methods are absent. If you’re looking for anything resembling a robust word processing/note taking application, you should go for the excellent Scratch word processor instead.




























14 Comments
Mmmmmmm Jot-0-licious
Tip and suggestion: the tip will be to use as well "evernote" and send the email to the evernote account for web and desktop usage. my suggestion will be that when we send the email of the note, we should have the opportunity that the subject of the email will be the first line of our note instead of "new note" so it could be ready to classified in evernote or any other cloud storage.
It only takes a few pixels up at the bottom border of the screen when the dashboard is minimized, far from what I'd consider 'clutter' and 'hinderance' Limiting your usage of the dashboard capabilities is more of a hinderance if you ask me. It's an amazing feature of the OS to allow an active, interactive, unobtrusive dashboard. I keep many apps active there; Jot It, Weather Dashboard, News Feed, Power Nap, not to mention temporary widgets like JogStats and Music controls. Gives you instant access & information. Also, what do you mean by "...I get a fair deal of text messages and emails throughout the day, and I
Thanks. It's nice to see a review that is not just a PR "puff" piece or where the author is too reticent to really lay out the pros AND cons of a product.
I'm sure the program reviewed has some value (different strokes for different folks, after all), but as long as we collectively continue to have the attitude that we are just happy to have anything, that is all we'll ever get.
I like the notification UI. It's not something I'd want open all the time, but it's useful for getting a new note generated (snap) instantly. If I'm going into a work situation where I know I'll be accumulating information,i would have it open and ready to note. Because I think one of the most important attributes for a note program is speed.
the other main factor, for how I work, is cloud backup. It's nice you can email, but after a phone crash it hit home I need a more automatic or global solution.
for this reason, I'm currently usinf "noted". It, too, is imperfect, but I really appreciate the sync feature.
I would definitely consider migrating back to Jot It if they incorporate a cloud sync. Other than that key feature, it feels like a good solid app to me.
EDIT: So apparently every time the page refreshes on my Pre after posting a comment on precentral, it re-posts it again. Is that a bug that can be fixed in the website's code?
Another duplicate post..
..and another..
My problem with the app (yes I have purchased it but don't currently use it is that the lined pages serve no purpose as once your not reaches more than one page and you try to scroll the lines remain static and your notes just drag, makes it really hard to look at. In the end add some formatting like bullets etc and the ability to turned off the lined pages and I might start using it again. http://bit.ly/9X4nrS
thank god I been waiting for this review. I have it and it sucks! The dev needs to iron out those bugs mentioned.
I like the app but the
and what's the deal with backup? If you can't make an app that will sync with google docs or back up to email straightforward it's useless. Hell no! I don't trust you sending a backup to an offsite foreign location so everytime I send a note to myself I receive it from "jotit@killingitllc.com" I mean so what hell is that?
I agree fully! A note app must be trustworthy otherwise it is useless. I'm the developer of "Sorting Thoughts" app and work currently on a sync feature over USB. You can see some preview screenshots here: http://post.ly/rzV5
Nice app review! I hope we will see reviews of other note apps like Sorting Thoughts http://www.precentral.net/app-gallery/app-catalog/sorting-thoughts or textPress! http://www.precentral.net/app-gallery/app-catalog/textpress or ...