Review: Touchstone compatible Otterbox case for Pre Series by Touchstonemods.com | webOS Nation
 
 

Review: Touchstone compatible Otterbox case for Pre Series by Touchstonemods.com 9

by Jonathan I Ezor#IM Thu, 10 Mar 2011 5:08 pm EST

As miraculous a technology as is the Touchstone, it has forced a choice on some users: whether to use the Touchstone or some non-compatible peripheral such as a case or external battery. Steve Burlbaw of TouchstoneMods.com, who previously created the solution for Seidio 2600 mA extended battery owners to also use a Touchstone, has just added a new product to his offerings: a Touchstone Compatible OtterBox case for the Pre, Pre Plus and Pre 2. We were lent one of these new Otterbox cases for a brief review.

For those that may not be familiar with Otterbox, they make sturdy yet attractive cases for a variety of devices including Palm smartphones. The Otterbox Pre case, similar to other covers, consists of two pieces: a flexible, protective and grip-enhancing overlay for the back of the Pre, and a thinner rim for the front that extends past the touchscreen, keeping it from impacting on the ground if it falls face down. Both are made from "impact-resistant polycarbonate with rubber over-molding" (according to Otterbox) and affixed with clips, which seem sturdier and less prone to snapping than those on the Seidio Innocase. On its own, the Otterbox is a bit too thick to allow sufficient magnetic field strength to penetrate to a standard Touchstone back for attaching or charging on the stone.

As with his previous Seidio conversion, Burlbaw transplants the charging contacts and other Touchstone hardware from a standard Pre back onto the Otterbox, using hot glue. To enable connection to the Pre's battery, Burlbaw has cleverly bored a small hole in a regular Pre back, precisely above the battery contacts.

When the altered back is snapped into rear half of the Otterbox case, the Touchstone contacts go through the hole to make a firm connection, pressed in place by the altered back's attachment to the Pre. The resulting device is indistinguishable from a standard Otterbox-enclosed Pre (with the exception that it charges on a Touchstone dock).

The conversion work on the Otterbox case is well-done, and it connects to a Touchstone a bit more strongly than does a regular Pre back (Burlbaw installs extra-strength magnets to enhance the connection). Nevertheless, the magnetic connection is not strong enough to hold the Otterbox-encased Pre on a vertical Touchstone mount on a dashboard; it slides off almost immediately. Additionally, the Otterbox case (whether or not converted) fits only over a standard Pre back, meaning that one cannot use an extended battery and an Otterbox case at the same time.

Finally, the converted case is pricey: $90 including shipping (although approximately $26-30 of that represents the retail cost of the Otterbox itself. Additionally, if you already own an Otterbox, you can send it to Burlbaw for conversion at reduced cost (which varies depending on whether you include your existing Pre back). If you are looking for ruggedized protection for your Pre-series webOS smartphone, use the standard-sized battery (or an extended one that fits under the standard back), and don't vertically mount your Touchstone, this Otterbox conversion may be worth considering.

Pros

Protection plus Touchstone convenience Good workmanship Stronger-than-stock magnets

Cons

Price may be steep for some Only works with standard-sized batteries Doesn't stick to vertical Touchstone mountings

Score

4.0

9 Comments

man... If this was available a few months ago I would have bought this so quickly! Just not worth it for a couple months of use :(

...what's the point anymore? Too bad really, looks like a great product.

actually it seems for those planning to stay with WebOS as long as possible, this might be more important than ever. we all thought we'd be upgrading to Pre3's soon, with replacement hardware readily available. now it looks like the Pre+ or Pre- in your hand right now is pretty much it. I was never willing to even consider giving up my touchstones, so never considered a case either. Still, $90 is a tough price (necessary I realize).

U forgot Pre 2 ;)

More pics, please!

Nice looking case...might pick one up if I decide to keep my Pre for awhile longer.

I might go for this for a Pre³. Not holding my breath on that, though.

I bought two of the earlier otterboxes and BOTH failed the same way - the tabs that are intended to grip the Pre failed w/n weeks.

I would not recommend these to others unless that part of the design is different.

Negative, Null, Nill, Niet..!!

Key takeaway is that no case will prevent failure of the weaknesses of the Pre's design, namely the micro usb connector... Understanding there are others and I am only naming the most known and flagrent.

Of course the slider is a weak link as well and again no usable case will prevent this from failing.

I do use some peelable screen protector even though I have to admit the glass on the device is incredibly sturdy.

I use a belt pouch that firmly closes preventing the device from falling off and use extra care in manipulating it. I will monitor ebay for fair bargains on an spare device and or Pre3 for the few that may go to market...

I also definitely hope that another manufacturer will deploy the hardware to keep webOS alive...

Sent from my webos powered and Preware enhanced Touchpad