Smartphone Round Robin webOS review from Android Central’s Casey Chan | webOS Nation
 
 

Smartphone Round Robin webOS review from Android Central’s Casey Chan 10

by Derek Kessler Tue, 29 Dec 2009 10:06 am EST

webOS and Android

The competition for “most open” software platform will always be a fierce one. It all depends on what your definition of “open” is. Do that mean open and easy development, like webOS, or do you mean completely open source, like Android? Our friend Casey Chan over at sister site Android Central last week got his robot paws on webOS in the form of the Palm Pre and Palm Pixi and was tasked with giving the world his impressions of the platform from the Android point of view.

Jumping headfirst into any platform is a new experience, so thankfully we’ve got the PreCentral forums to help out both novices and experts alike. You all in the community stepped up to the plate to give Casey a crash course in webOS 101.

So what did Casey think about webOS? In truth, there’s a lot on paper that seems very similar about the two operating systems. They both support full multitasking, they both have unobtrusive notifications, the both have application stores, and they both work on capacitive multitouch screens (well, Android is a sometimes in that category). But the similarities end there, and Android does have a year’s start on the relatively fresh webOS. We don’t want to give away all of Casey’s thoughts and observations about the first efforts of Palm’s rebirth, so we’ll just give you a link to Android Central where you can check them out for yourself.

Once you’re done with that, we’re sure you’ll be on a webOS high, so we want to keep it going by giving you a webOS phone. It’s a giveaway! All you have to do to enter the contest is leave a post in a Smartphone Round Robin thread on the PreCentral forums and once this all wraps up we’ll pick a winner. As always, the rules for these contests are suggested reading. Casey has already passed off the Pre and Pixi to Kevin Michaluk of CrackBerry.com - Kevin’s going to need the ease of webOS after a week with Windows Mobile, while our own Dieter Bohn is about to get some face time with BlackBerry.

10 Comments

First paragraph, third sentence, the word 'that' should be 'you'. :)

Android has
-Skype
-GPU Support
-SIP
-More Speed

... want to sell my Pre and buy a Motorola Milestone (Droid)
But nobody wants to buy the Pre ....

i Wished the Milestone (Drpod) with Android 2.0 has been released 2 Months earlyer....

WebOS >> Android

I loved the review. But in some cases I would have to diagree with you. Like I would take the pre over the droid any day. And ever since the 1.3.5 update came out it just made the pre even more better. Once we get flash, a cam that records vids, and games that can rivail iphones. I expect a lot of heads to turn their way back to the Pre. Btw I'm a first time palm user.

I think this review just points out the differences between a 1st generation device/os and one that is established. The real comparason would be looking at where webos/the Pre is at 6 months past launch compared to where the first android devices were at 6 months past launch.

Do you think we could get these reviewers a completely Stock Pre to use? The one in his hand obviously has a theme on it and it is clearly patched.

Everyone knows that patching and themeing slows down the Pre and makes it less stable.

Understand what you're saying, but this is part of growing pains. Newer OS' are competing with established OS'. Therefore all comparison are to be done with the most recent of technology. I know this seemed unfair, but consumer aren't basing their purchase on yesterday tech, it's for today's and the future.

I'm a strong believer in Palm and webOS. Having use the webOS for 6 months, I can say the pros out weight the cons. Yes, the OS is at times painfully sluggish. Yes there are features missing that should have been included, and they will be included with future updates. And yes, the hardware needs better built quality.

Although I am frustrated by the Pre's short comings, I would have been greatly saddened if Palm had delayed the release of this product to address all these problems, and so is true for all of you.

As a new user to WebOS who had never considered palm when purchasing smart phones, I am to the highest degree impress with WebOS and look forward to growing with this platform. What makes WebOS great is not the individual features: multitasking, notifications, universal search, OTA updates, and UI). It's the seamless way which all these features compliment each other that are truly genius.

It's Just gonna get better folks, be patient.

The video player on the droid just plain sucks, now the pre look like HD in a side by side to the droid.

Am I the only one that sits through the Droid adds and says "yes and it did 6 months ago." to every question?

Sorry but the Droid is a brick and feels dated. The 2 or 3 droids and Heros I've played with seemed to have a very limited UI. I found myself wishing to use gestures like swipe and pinch and zone the whole time.

Bigger screen? Really? This is media and content on the go that is at arms length at worst. If I wanted a huge device I would have gotten a Netbook instead. I want a portable device that I can fit in pocket and I can only tell it's with me when I need it, not a WWII era walkie talkie.

Home screens? Who needs them? Do these people still uses Yahoo or MS for their browser home page? Being able to quickly open apps and navigate to and from them is much more efficient then a page full of minimal information.

I agree with a previous post that prior to webOS 1.3.5 I would agree with this review and would definitely consider switching to Android if I could.

However now that webOS 1.3.5 has been released, I have completely fallen in love with my Pre again. I can now get back to more than 3 cards open without receiving the "too many cards error" (and yes I would've normally run this many cards at 1 time). My Pre is faster and responds better. My calendar is opening up and loading quicker. It feels like my battery is now lasting longer (only been 1 day).

So with possibly more features coming down the pike, GPU support and video recording just to name a few, I'm back on board with the Pre and think that Palm can pick up steam.

As a side note to Palm....don't EVER EVER EVER let us down with such a buggy release (1.3.1)!!!!